In Reply To #15
I understand what are you saying.
You are right, his first games were great (AOS is the 2nd best Castlevania of all time, IMO, the best is still CVIII) except HOD (I just can't love it, I mean, God, it's a disguised SOTN, and Juste with white hair...hmmmmm... oh, and don't forget the ultra original plot about the maid in troubles...) Two of the DS games were excellent too (POR sucks, a good idea, a bad development) and the 3D games were... deccent.
But the point is, IGA just can't think in anything new and as shocking as SOTN was. He can make more un-justified games with the same formula and perhaps I would love them anyway, but I'm just getting tired of the same metroidvania thing, oh, and don't forget the God-Alucard and the weak downgraded Belmonts.
What I like from IGA is that certainly he loves the saga, and, in the paper, all his games are strong and with all the good intentions in the world, but in the end he's uncapable of striving for making a new shocking experience that could make said "OMG, is that Castlevania? IMpossible!, is too great and beautiful to be it" and the lack of vision kills his work. I hate when he says things like this:
I can make many games with the same formula, anyway, fans will love it
And certainly, some fans are REALLY TIRED of the same formula.
Ecclesia is a great game, is almost perfect, the only thing that I don't like is the fact that was so predictable, but what I really liked was the fusion between old and new school, I had faith in IGA at those times, but there came the Judgment, and i said to myself "That's it, that's what IGA consideres a great game" and I lost all my faith.
For his games, I'm just expecting another MetroidVania with no sense at all (Historically) that tries to be tied with the storyline and in the end isn't at all.
Oh, and I forgot about the main 3 things
- Alucard is the hero after all (Or he appears or he's mentioned