[1] - As we know by Portrait's dialogue, John Morris condition was deteriorating due to using the whip. However, by the same dialogue, he was still alive enough to train Jonathan in the basics. So, in my story, while his condition was not
that bad yet, Eric set out to look for a way to cure him.
[2] - This, along with
[4], was one of the major pieces of info/connection I used to build this story.
At first, I though that the "STELLAr Sword" sounding so alike to the name of one of the sisters was just a silly coincidence, since "stellar" is a word derivative from "something related to the stars." Soooo, in japanese, the sword's name may read/sound something like "Sword of the Stars (恒星の剣)" or maybe have "Hoshi (恒星)" somewhere in it's name right? RIGHT? Well, would you look at these curious images!:
The first one is from Harmony of Dissonance's japanese manual. The second one is from the official Portrait of Ruin character portraits. You see the katakana? The one under Maxim is talking about the Stellar Sword. The other is Stella's name.
They are EXACTLY THE SAME. The sword is named Stella!
So, from there I drew the first connections: Eric has the Stellar Sword... Stella's name is the same as a sword which
just happens to be under Eric's possession... Therefore, Stella was named after an important relic in her family: The Stellar Sword.
Why would such a relic be so important? Well, because just maybe it was from her mother's side and represented something important? I know, big leap here, but as I said before, fanfiction is unavoidable.
As I had established before that Daniela was Maxim's descendant due to the "secret art" bit, and as the game showed us the Daniela had a sentimental connection with Shanoa, the whole connection was set: The sword was passed down from Maxim to Daniela, from Daniela to Shanoa, and from Shanoa to her children, until it reached Eric through his wife, who descended from Shanoa.
Now, how to show that this wife could be a descendant of Shanoa? That's what I'll try to do in
[4].
[3] - Portrait never mentions Eric's wife anywhere, but we know it's a second one due to his first girl, Gwendolyn, being vampirized by Elizabeth.
After analysing the game, I started thinking she died very early, specifically because she's never, ever mentioned. Even in the locket, she's not present. Furthermore, in the Sisters Mode at the beginning, the sisters express zero concern for a possible mother, and too much for Eric. This all indicates (to me) that a mother is not present at all, because she died too long ago to be relevant right now.
[4] - Here is the other part of the big connection thing I stated in
[2]; I knew that the "Stella" bit was important, but I also knew it was not strong enough to set up the whole "Stella and Loretta are descendants of Shanoa through their mother" plot convincingly. I needed to find a way to get the goddamn Stellar Sword to Eric's hands, so I set to look for a last evidence that I could retroactivelly rationalize.
Stella received the name of the sword, so, what did Loretta inherit? She inherited Shanoa's natural gift of using Glyph magic, that's what.
Looking for a way to connect the sisters to Shanoa, I stumbled upon the game's graphics. Look at this:
This picture is Loretta's magic spritesheet. See the blue circle with symbols all over it there? It looks a hell of a lot like a giant glyph. Sure, it could be merely a magic circle of course, and therefore it was still not strong enough evidence for me to convince myself that she could be using a variation of Glyph magic, a trait that she could've inherited from Shanoa herself. Stella also uses a magical attack that looks a lot like Shanoa's Pneuma, only much stronger. Like Loretta's magic looks like a much stronger version of Shanoa's Grando. But STILL was not enough of an interpretation, so I went to watch the Stella/Loretta boss battle.
Skip to 1:12:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pyz39w_FqyIDid you see it? The ice sword attack? Do you remember who also could do it, with a movement scarily similar? She could:
We DID see in Order of Ecclesia that Shanoa could do a Grando Glyph Union like this. If she equips Grando in one arm, and a sword glyph in the other, this attack comes out.
Now, with the help of Loretta's magic, Stella can do it too. And if you pay close attention, it's almost as if they
were a Glyph Union...
Where one is the "arm" with the sword glyph and the other is the "arm" with the ice glyph.This all made me think that yes, this looks like a convincing interpretation of things. The sisters are performing a "Glyph Union" where one represents the sword property, and the other represents the ice property, reflecting Shanoa's use of the attack with one sword glyph arm, and one ice glyph arm.
Another evidence that the sisters compliment each other is hinted by their eyes: Each one has a different red eye. As if they are indeed meant to be combined, just like two arms in a Glyph Union.
Therefore I drew the last connections: Loretta inherited properties from Shanoa's ice glyphs, and Stella inherited properties from Shanoa's sword/wind glyphs. Both of them combined allow them to execute a "glyph union"-like attack, due to having inherited these powers.
And let's not forget that Ecclesia states that Shanoa is a natural, that she possesses something on her makeup that allows for her to grasp Glyphs much easier than anyone else. It IS something on her blood or spirit. What if she were to have descendants?
Now, after aaaaall this you could say "Ah, but what if Eric was the one to actually descend from Shanoa, and therefore have the sword?"; Sure, it could be, but there is a problem: We never see Eric display
any similarity with Shanoa at all. Not in the magic, not in the dual wielding, nothing. From who could the sisters have inherited these traits then? The only answer left is "from their mother."
[5] - This explains how Eric got the sword from his wife while there being no wife to receive it from. It also explains how Jonathan can use the art while having the sword: Eric taught him after learning it from his dying wife.
[6] - This is present in the Sisters Mode dialogue. The sisters say that Eric told them to not come, but they follow him anyway after him being out for too long.
[7] - This is meant to explain how do they know the technique even if Eric is dead, and why they got taught it in the first place. Eric knew that the rising of Dracula's Castle is a bad sign, so this is why he set out to hunt Brauner and why he taught his daughters how to unlock the whip's power. When the castle appears, someone with the whip is not too far behind.