91
General Castlevania Discussion / Leon killing Sara
« Last post by Scarlet starlet on February 15, 2026, 11:09:22 AM »It was such a disappointing moment in my opinion. Because Sara still was an innocent person when Leon striked her, which makes the latter a murderer. With Rinaldo clearly manipulating him into doing it to unlock the alchemy whip true power ("you are dishonoring youself!", he says).
It makes the entire Belmont dynasty founded on killing an innocent person who wasn't even a vampire yet which isn't something I really like.
But the real problem is that other games like Portrait of Ruin and Legacy of Darkness showed us that vampires CAN be saved (via a spell, like Stella/Loretta/the monk, or via divine grace like Rosa).
Also nowhere it is stated that a turned vampire in Castlevania is always 100% evil. Rosa was fighting against it all the time, and I'm sure the whole Sara situation could have been handled differently by the writers.
Sara should have simply became a vampire, then turn against Leon. Then in-battle at some point she would have struggled against her newfound evil nature and let herself be struck. Then Rinaldo cutscene with the blood pact. Sara dies and the whip is made. There are 100 other ways to write this plot point without forcing Leon to become a murderer.
It makes the entire Belmont dynasty founded on killing an innocent person who wasn't even a vampire yet which isn't something I really like.
But the real problem is that other games like Portrait of Ruin and Legacy of Darkness showed us that vampires CAN be saved (via a spell, like Stella/Loretta/the monk, or via divine grace like Rosa).
Also nowhere it is stated that a turned vampire in Castlevania is always 100% evil. Rosa was fighting against it all the time, and I'm sure the whole Sara situation could have been handled differently by the writers.
Sara should have simply became a vampire, then turn against Leon. Then in-battle at some point she would have struggled against her newfound evil nature and let herself be struck. Then Rinaldo cutscene with the blood pact. Sara dies and the whip is made. There are 100 other ways to write this plot point without forcing Leon to become a murderer.

Recent Posts