In that case
Maybe there could be one for fans that only support the new, rebooted timeline & pay no mind to the traditional saga. (icon can be.. a combat cross sprite?)
Or one for fans that cosplay with no shame.
Or one that is specific to lurkers? (be it subforum-specific, or otherwise)
Or one that specializes in programming/designing hacks, Castlevania-related or otherwise
Another one could be for those that don't necessarily enjoy the games themselves, but certain aspects of the games only (artwork, music, etc.) this could be iffy to determine tho.
A smartass award, for those that think they know everything about CV just from playing a few games (most likely ROMs) & watching videos on youtube
Or.. one for fans that have been supporting Castlevania since the 80's (this may be difficult to determine as well)
also... how about a "Brutally Honest" award, for those that are harsh critics & don't sugarcoat their opinions, be it directed at games, artwork, fan-stuff, etc.
for icons,
Lurkers- Peeping Eye

Hackers- Automation ZX27

Supporters since the 80's- Tombstone

Smartasses- Jonathan Morris
Highwind Dragoon qualifies for Town Crier for his incessant yahoo stories
Abnormal Freak definately gets THE PERV

Nagumo can also get the Great Defender..
Kale gets a Permanent Resident possibly