I understand this as making main title functioning menu music.
All I have is one vote, but here is what I'll be listening for.
*A melody (hook) that sticks with you long after you hear it.
*A song that sets a mood for the hypothetical game.
*People stay in menus. I'll be listening for a nice seamless loop.
*A strong direction, and a straightforward arrangement that introduces the theme melody quickly, but tastefully.
*Original melodies (not a requirement I believe). Just saying that because that's what I want to vote for.
I'm pretty obsessed with themes and little melodies that linger in your head. I'm excited to hear what you guys come up with. I'd be participating if I weren't needing every spare second to finish my work. But it will be fun to listen and vote!
Happy composing friends!