In Reply To #13
Well no, I say this about any game that people claim to be "OMG GRATEST GAEM EVAR", too. Yeah. It's a fantastic game, I won't deny that at all. But it just came out, it was a highly anticipated game, and it's part of a series that has never disappointed fans.
Play the game again after a few months, or a couple years, after some more blockbusters and sleeper hits come out, and then see if you still feel the same way. Until then, it's just an awesome shiny new toy that everyone loves and wants.