I aore the musical, but don't love the movie version of it so much. I think that Emmy's vocal type wasn't quite right for Christine, I found her singing voice a bit nasal and just didn't have the right colour to it. Gerard Butler was wonderful eye candy (I love him in Dracula 2000), but he wasn't experienced enoug a singer, so I can tell where they had to digitally tweak/extend his notes with the autotune. I thought Minnie Driver was hilarious as Charlotta, but they snubbed the lady a lot who'd provided Charlotta's singing voice aferwards, which wasn't good. I also disliked that they trimmed Phantom's Theme in the film, and downplayed Erik's disfigurement to the point where it barely looked like the big issue it was meant to be, over how monstrous he looked. That said, I love it that a movie was made of the ALW musical. I have a lot of love for Phantom films in general. Dario Argento's 'horror' version is hilarious, especially as Erik isn't disfigured physically, he's just completely off his rocker and insane after being raised by rats. Has anyone seen Love Nnever Dies, either the original production or the reworked Australian production that was released on dvd? As much as I love Ramin and Sierra as Erik and Christine, and I love how much more skeletal they made Erik's disfigurement look, the soundtrack cd I found painful to listen to in places because of the wording. It was bad. The Australian reworking was so much better, but still it's not a patch on Phantom. The Phantom of Manhatten book that LND shares a source with is equally bad.