i meant more as an overall thing. charlotte was just a decoration meant to be there just to look pretty. no part of the storyline was about her, she was just an addon, a tool to help move one or two scenes forward.
other than that she was on the level of vincent, as in a comical relief character. but then again, half of the cast of that game were comical relief characters, main hero included.
books can be used better too. cyrille in shining force exa also uses books to fight, but instead of that silly copout they did in pork she hits physically and combos with them, and as either a finisher/special attack or spell attack she casts spells from them, with each book having different sets of spells.