Castlevania Dungeon Forums

The Castlevania Dungeon Forums => General Castlevania Discussion => Topic started by: Lumi Kløvstad on November 20, 2026, 07:07:42 AM

Title: I do not get the "canon issues" supposedly surrounding Brauner in BC
Post by: Lumi Kløvstad on November 20, 2026, 07:07:42 AM
Like, the whole thing was mostly predicated around "but Brauner didn't serve Dracula and didn't show up until 1944!"

I thought the game did a good job of explaining it: it's a whole family, and this is NOT the same Brauner that we see in Portrait of Ruin. And like "identical ancestor" is absolutely a time honored trope, even a cliche at times. Like, this is Brauner!44's great great great something grandfather who DID serve Dracula (well, for a given quality of "served"), and who seems to have pioneered the techniques we'll see Brauner!44 elaborate on to create the Painted Worlds, but using his prototype version to displace Notre Dame Cathedral in a bubble world instead rather than spin one from whole cloth (or is that paint?).

Like he's very much his own guy and has a different personality to boot.

I know Brauner!44 turned to vampirism after his daughters were killed in World War 1, but that... doesn't necessarily conflict with what we're given in Belmont's Curse. He may or may not have been aware of the history of vampirism in his family.

Also I found Brauner folding like a cheap suit against Rose to be funny. As others have said, "every group has the rich boy wimp" and "up until this point all he did was whine in letters about how he's an "artiste". Its a pretty old trope, the self-important villain who's actually a pushover. His cooler characterization comes from his Machivellian personality after you beat him."

I dunno. I feel like the "canon issues" crowd here is making mountains out of molehills.

Which is not to say the game isn't otherwise full of canon and timeline issues, but of all the things I've seen people online fixate on, it's Brauner for some reason: the one the game actually does a pretty good job of reconciling with prior lore.
Title: Re: I do not get the "canon issues" supposedly surrounding Brauner in BC
Post by: Gunlord on November 21, 2026, 02:49:53 PM
Eh...I disagree. You're right that they made an effort to explain it, but the explanation doesn't make that much sense. Even if we say Brauner!44 is merely a descendant of French!Brauner, why does he look almost exactly the same? You'd think there'd be more significant differences if !44 brauner was just in the family as opposed to a clone or the same person. I woulda been more satisfied with plain old time travel tbqvh.
Title: Re: I do not get the "canon issues" supposedly surrounding Brauner in BC
Post by: Scarlet starlet on November 21, 2026, 04:52:28 PM
No it doesn't, Death in Portrait knows no Brauner. Same with Arikado in Grimoire of Souls

Quote
Charlotte: I get it. You've joined forces with Brauner because you're thinking of resurrecting Dracula, aren't you?
Death: Brauner... Who are you talking about?
Jonathan: There's no point in playing dumb! We already know the current master of this castle is a vampire by the name of Brauner!
Death: Vampire Brauner... Even with my power, I didn't sense that. It seems I have been dormant for far too long.

Quote
Lucy: In this era, it seems the castle is sealed in a painting. Dracula and the castle's magic are separated.

Arikado: What?! How did this happen?

Lucy: According to the records, a vampire called Brauner did it to take advantage of the castle's magic.

Arikado: I remember a vampire called Olrox amongst my father's ranks, but the name Brauner doesn't ring any bells.

Brauner was clearly written by Ida as a tragic character and a new vampire who took everyone by surprise. Him having a silly ancestor undermines the character.