I completely agree. They shouldn't mess with anything. All they need to do is translate it and sell it. Nothing more.
I concur
Till recently, I always thought that a game/anime that doesn't have any made up stuff in the dialogue is a literal translation. I now realize a literal translation would be a translator keeping the dialogue in the same grammical structure in japanese.
With that said, I love translations of video games and anime that doesn't add extra things in despite the dialgoue being ''rewritten'' just to make it flow better for english speakers since I want to read the game writer's idea to the story and not some freelance translator who added somethin in just to get recongization.
Although, the Ace Attorny games have been localized heavily, I think the later games received an exceellent job in translation. Only the setting (which I think is silly to do, but understandable) and character naames (to perseve name punss) were modified whereas the dialogue is unchanged from the japanese script.
The only reason I can see them making Soma into an exchange student for the west is to help the gamers to identify better with Soma
However, l find this localization moot since a lot of gamers are comfortable playing a japanese character in a video game.