1.The Glyph system is basically a rehash of all of the other GBAs' and DS' combination combat systems.
2.Original costume? Are you fucking serious? This is one of your defensive arguments? Every character has an "original" costume.
3.Oh please. The "apparent good guy turning out to be the bad guy and vice versa" scenario is nothing original. It's a cliche'.
4.No, the plot twist was not good. As I already stated. It was a cliche'.
5.A drawback to using a certain weapon. Hmmm...sounds familiar. Where did I see this before? Maybe in the previous game, PoR? Morris' and the Vampire Killer ring a bell?
6.So? It's original because the character is a different sex? That's ridiculous. Especially, when she is a rehash of a previous character.
7.The main protagonist of a video game having to save a village!? How original!!!
8.A clan raising and training one of their own to destroy Dracula? Cough*TheBelmonts*Cough
9.Leon was forced to kill his wife, Trevor lost an eye and was stabbed in the heart from behind, Simon was cursed and forced to resurrect and battle Dracula a second time, Richter was put under a spell, destroying the Belmont name and the ability to wield the Vampire Killer for hundreds of years, Alucard had to slay his own father, etc. I see nothing special about Shanoa's sacrifice compared to all the others.
10.Alucard would break Shanoa into pieces.
If you'd like, we can pick through every Castlevania game in the series and find an abundance of overused cliches. Ecclesia is no more guilty of this than SotN.
However, I do think that Shanoa is one of the better Castlevania characters. At least relative the stars of the other DS entries. I do really like her outfit; it looks good. The long, flowing hair is a nice touch. She's sexy without looking completely slutty like most Japanese game characters; I appreciate that. I can take her seriously as a dangerous woman but still enjoy looking at her. I think the artist did a great job on the visuals of the character.
In personality, all right, she's a little cliche (omg wut happen 2 my emotions!!!!!11) but at least she's a huge step up from the pathetic PorK personalities, and she's way more badass than Soma. Who was a major douche.
But I do have to agree that Alucard could rip Shanoa to shreds.