What he probably means to say is that by looking at that list it seems more likely that you have a love for horror-genre games rather than Castlevania specifically.
If the only Castlevania games you like are from Lords of Shadow series than this seems even more likely because most of what they have in common with the rest of the series is their names, hence it being a reboot series.
Most of the older Castlevania fans would most likely not count them as being Castlevania games because of this.
This is not saying that you can or cannot like Lords of Shadow of course.