Well I'm not sure if I'm allowed to post anything here since it's been a while, but I want to answer The SilverLord and I think this a great topic, very accessible to everybody. So forgive me if I'm breaking any rules, it is not my intent.
To start off, I would say that those early Dracula movies you were speaking of, are probably still scary to this day. Never really watched them, but I did see some scenes here and there in documentaries and boy, is that bald Nosferatu something. I mean, I'm a grown man now, and I still find him scary. There is a quality to these black and white movies that I think is probably impossible to re-create in this day and age. And I might be wrong, but those were silent movies right? I think it adds even more mystery/horror to the experience. It lets you use your imagination and somehow , I find that having Drac just staring at the camera without saying a word is 10000 times scarier (than those Blade vampires for example) and prevents the character from ruining the vision you have of him.
As for the Lord of Shadows thing, well, I have to admit I'm not the biggest fan. I mean, I don't mind some changes and I have to give them credit for trying, but my opinion is they went overboard with that. That game didn't feel like Castlevania to me. From the soundtrack to the gameplay, I mean this game could have been called something else entirely. However, that was for LOS. I did find myself enjoying Mirror of fate quite a bit. Maybe because of the return to 2d. But there is something else. It's hard to explain, but the ««feel»» of the game, the general mood of it, for some reason, felt more castlevania-ish to my eyes. I just didn't like the whole (Spoiler ahead) Trevor is Alucard plot. Trevor is my favorite belmont and to make him a vampire is a travesty in my opinion lol! Asides from that, loved the little puzzles, loved the fact that you had to do some backtracking (symphony style, not to the same extent but still) and appreciated the soundtrack more. Although, OST speaking, I always thought the one-stage, one-music setting always fitted the franchise better. I mean, Castlevania has some of the best music in videogame history and I find that the quality went downhill in the last installments. Although, this a very personnal question of taste. I've always prefered catchy classical-rock pieces of music over generic scores. Generic soundtracks are not that appealing to me, but I understand that this is not the same type of castlevania and in this case, was well done. Keep in mind that I am a old conservative nostalgic fool, and games truly have to be special to move me. Don't even start me on Final fantasy 13 lol

At the end of the day, t's all a matter of opinion, and I respect all opinions. So that's it. Don't know if u will see this because it has been a while, but it's always a pleasure to exchange with fellow Castlevania fans!