Thanks for the suggestion! I'm actually almost done with most of the weapons. Knives are done. I actually went the more realistic route and used a Kunai knife with a painted brass handle. (Yes I know kunai's are a seperate subweapon but it felt awkward just using a regular dagger)
Holy water is finished minus the stopper which I'm either going to purchase an antique cross stopper or make one out of clay and paint it an antique gold.
Stopwatch is done. Just bought a silver stopwatch and added a small cross emblem on the front.
Still working on Axe, Bible, and the whip. I've actually decided to go with the chain whip. I'm going to make it myself or at least piece it together. Get my hands on a morningstar head, a metal handle, and a large chain link and hopefully it will all come together nicely!