Author [EN] [PL] [ES] [PT] [IT] [DE] [FR] [NL] [TR] [SR] [AR] [RU] [ID] Topic: Limewire fined 75 Trillion Dollars by RIAA  (Read 2447 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Zobias

  • Guest
Limewire fined 75 Trillion Dollars by RIAA
« on: March 25, 2011, 04:05:58 PM »
0
It's been nearly a decade since the music industry declared war against file sharers via its controversial policy of suing individuals supposedly identified via their IP addresses. After all this time one would expect the various companies to present a consistent, united front. As a recent court filing against Limewire shows this is absolutely not the case. Last May, federal district court judge Kimba Wood granted the record industry's request for a summary judgement against Limewire. With their winning ticket in hand, the RIAA withdrew to contemplate the level of statutory and punitive damages it felt Limewire should pay. The recording studios have never been overly interested in due diligence or common sense but this latest tops all.

Limewire, the plaintiffs allege, owes them between $400 billion and 75 trillion. The latter, written out, comes to 75,000,000,000,000.


Everyone, meet Jeeves.
When not starring in Tarzan movies or enjoying the finer things in life, he moonlights as an account for the music industry.

We decided to graph a handful of additional values to put the $75 trillion in context. World GDP for 2011 is expected to be ~$65 trillion, the US national debt is currently $14.25 trillion, and the total median income for all 114,825,428 US households in 2010 is just $5.7 trillion. In other words, every single US household would have to spend all of its income buying nothing but music for over 13 years in order to arrive at what the music industry has deemed a reasonable settlement. Even the lower figure of $400 billion still amounts to seven percent of total household income in the entire country.



The legal question at the center of these absurdly high judgements is whether or not the plaintiffs can demand statutory damages from each individual infringement. A simple example is as follows: Assume that the record industry is able to recover $10 in statutory damages each time Song XYZ is shared. If 10,000 people download Song XYZ, Limewire is on the hook for $100,000 in statutory damages from just one song. If Limewire had a library of 100 songs, each of which is downloaded by 10,000 people, it'd be on the hook for $10 million.

The alternative reading is that the plaintiffs are only eligible to recover statutory damages based on the number of songs shared. If Limeware shared 100 songs, as above, it would be required to pay damages of $10 per song or $1000 total. The enormous gap between these two figures is a genuine problem for modern copyright law. Judge Wood writes: "To the best of this Court's knowledge, the issue of whether a plaintiff should be able to recover from a secondarily liable defendant multiple awards per work based on the number of direct infringers... has never been addressed in a context where the secondarily liable defendant has enabled hundreds, if not thousands, of individuals to infringe."

Having acknowledged the problem, she rules that the plaintiffs are only eligible to recover a single statutory reward per work infringed. One of the strongest arguments against the claim that Limewire owes up to $75 trillion is that it violates the judicial precept of absurdity. In arguing that Limewire should be eligible for damages on every individual download, the studios were effectively arguing that Limewire owed it more money than the entire record industry has made since Edison invented the phonograph in 1877.

This decision is important because it both acknowledges a legitimate gap in copyright law while slapping down the recording industry's blatant stupidity. It's incredibly ironic that the music studios, who unquestionably have the most to gain from balanced copyright law that addresses digital media while maintaining fair use, instead paint themselves in motley. Even if Wood had agreed with their logic, no higher court would have allowed a $400 billion fine to stand against one company. Ridiculous moves like this leave us wondering how sincere the music industry is when it speaks of finding common ground.

Source:
http://hothardware.com/News/Record-L...on-in-Damages/



Offline Kale

  • The Ophidian Lord
  • Master Hunter
  • *****
  • Posts: 2836
  • Gender: Male
  • Awards One-Time Show: Not quite a lurker, but posts infrequently and in only few areas. Permanent Resident: Seems to always be around to post/reply.
    • Awards
  • Likes:
Re: Limewire fined 75 Trillion Dollars by RIAA
« Reply #1 on: March 25, 2011, 05:41:12 PM »
0
It's not a fine.. that's different. It's a claim. Totally different.

That said, this is beyond ridiculous. I agree.

Offline X

  • Xenocide
  • Master Hunter
  • *****
  • Posts: 8762
  • Gender: Male
  • Awards SuperOld Dungeonite: Members who have been around since the oldOLD days. The Unfazed: Never loses his/her calm, even in the most heated arguments. The Retro Gamer: Has a heated passion for the oldschool VG Titles.
    • Awards
  • Favorite Game: Super Castlevania IV (SNES)
  • Likes:
Re: Limewire fined 75 Trillion Dollars by RIAA
« Reply #2 on: March 25, 2011, 05:58:31 PM »
0
75 trillion?? Who the hell has THAT much money besides the government!? Certainly not the super rich.

-X
"Spirituality is God's gift to humanity...
Religion is Man's flawed interpretation of Spirituality given back to humanity..."

Zobias

  • Guest
Re: Limewire fined 75 Trillion Dollars by RIAA
« Reply #3 on: March 25, 2011, 06:07:03 PM »
0
The Unfortunate truth is that with that new IP law and the fact that the US economy is tanked the only option open to companies is to sue for large sums of money.

Offline Kale

  • The Ophidian Lord
  • Master Hunter
  • *****
  • Posts: 2836
  • Gender: Male
  • Awards One-Time Show: Not quite a lurker, but posts infrequently and in only few areas. Permanent Resident: Seems to always be around to post/reply.
    • Awards
  • Likes:
Re: Limewire fined 75 Trillion Dollars by RIAA
« Reply #4 on: March 25, 2011, 07:21:05 PM »
0
This is not a lawsuit to get money, it's a lawsuit to kill Limewire, no company really has anything close to that.

Offline Abnormal Freak

  • luvz Elizabeth B.
  • Master Hunter
  • *****
  • Posts: 7268
  • Gender: Male
  • Swanktastic
  • Awards The Pervert: Sneaks in any and all innuendo into threads that he/she can. ICVD Denizen: Those that dwell in the corrupted, mirror image of The Dungeon. The Music Fanatic: Listens to a large collection of music, posts lyrics, etc. SuperOld Dungeonite: Members who have been around since the oldOLD days.
    • Swankster's Backloggery
    • Awards
  • Favorite Game: Castlevania (NES/etc)
  • Likes:
Re: Limewire fined 75 Trillion Dollars by RIAA
« Reply #5 on: March 26, 2011, 01:17:42 AM »
0
Guess Limewire better start paying visits to The Magic Money-Forming Well.
Oh yeah, and also:
meat

Soda as well.

Tags: