LoI was "that sucks!" I would have been in tears if the direction led to the audience getting to know Sara....
I've yet to play the game recently, so I'll give an update when I make the PS2 revisited go.
SoTN made me feel that Dracula wanted to redeem himself for the sake of Lisa, And Life then goes on...
Even playing all the ports at least five times, I still feel the same way and the Dracula Ark should have ended in Castlevania, PoR proved you can have a good cV story without dracula.
LoS was full of Holy shit, and Oh mai gah! scenes, but of course, it looked ungodly cool, but didn't provoke too much emotion since it was very action driven.
OoE did however bring me to tears, I understood Shanoa's goal and her situation, the idea of gaining your emotions back just to have the first feeling being Joy over accomplishing the defeat of Dracula and Sadness to lose the closest person to you, it is very bitter sweet. Tears of joy and Sadness.
I am sorta a tough guy but does stay intact with emotions, when I was a teenager I was all "men don't cry" and all that stuff...
now its different, and my photographic memory gets the best of me...
I can't listen to Aerith's theme from FF7, Any form of it makes me break down a bit.