I disagree with that, the last animated seen I recall seeing was with Griffith telling Guts he wanted to know his place in the world. That scene looked good to me compared to the cgi. Although the cgi is more consistent.
Far as I remember, this is the only 2D scene longer than a couple seconds that actually looked good. Most of the time, the 2D scenes are awful if animated.
In terms of the movie trilogy, they cut so much character development from Egg of the King that it destroyed all the emotion. That film should've pumped its brakes and ended with the Zodd battle. Battle for Doldrey and the last film handled the pacing much better.
I will state that one thing I did not like about Egg of the King is that they cut out almost the entire arc with the younger versions of the characters. Guts' whole spiel about not being that same man to Casca didn't really hold any meaning in the film, since we didn't really get to see what kind of man he used to be. So I'll agree with you there. Granted, I watched these films immediately after the '97 anime so it didn't really feel as off to me.
I -do- like that Guts and Griffith's first fight had the dialogue going on
during their fight though. It really helped with the pacing there, instead of having them stop fighting every time they talked. The Battle for Doldrey was far better as far as the pacing, but I felt The Advent completely nailed it, having my favorite rendition of The Eclipse, beating out both the manga and the '97 anime.
As for this series, pacing is definitely not its strong suit and if it was similar to the 96 anime and covered the black swordsman arc then I'd probably love it, despite cgi.
See, this is what I thought the series was going to be, and what it was originally advertised as: an adaptation of the Black Swordsman arc. And originally what I thought was, "How are they going to stretch out an 8-chapter arc over 24 episodes?" What I thought was going to happen is we were going to have an occasional episode with a bit slow pacing, which would have been fine.
Instead what we're getting is a 24-episode adaptation of the Conviction arc, so now I'm thinking "how the hell are they going to shove the
entire Conviction arc (save Lost Children, which was mysteriously cut out) into 24 episodes?" And here's how: they're speeding through so much content per episode it's hard to enjoy any of it. Something happens, and before you can even take in what's happening, poof, it's gone.