So far I'm enjoying lords of shadow, though I'm not too far, I'm only at Cornell now. While I like the game a lot, I don't particularly like it as a Castlevania game. So far it doesn't feel like CV, the atmosphere make it feel more like a traditional medieval story or something from Tolkien, which I'm not really a big fan of. It doesn't have that gothic feel, but like I said, I'm only at Cornell, that could change.
I'm going to look forward to a sequel and the DLC, but I hope Iga still does his games. I'm just glad this doesn't fit into the traditional canon. I hope it stays with the two seperate storylines