Where the hell did everyone read you will be layin AS Gabriel in 1999? I think's that's pretty much unlikely, I think Gab will be the bad one in the "present" MS game (Not that the NEXT one will set in modern days, more so considering that Simon and Alucard are confirmed to appear in next titles) even if it's the "wrong" bad guy according to the story.
Now, the 2Ds game, I'm hoping for a 2D MercurySteam game. I loved how combat was managed in the 2.5 D stages of LoS and mercuryEngine is capable of Holy shit graphics so I would love them to make a 2.5/2D game
Because the potential is huuuuuge. We got a taste of playing as Dracula with Soma, but he was sort of a puss and didn't really feel like a vampire.
Now, once again the dilemma is big. We could get more Mercury Steam games that follow the LoS 3D formula and give us Belmonts vs Dracula and all the awesome things we know - and I think nobody here would say "no" to that. It's what CV has been for 20 years, I guess some could say something new could be good, but in the end it would be the safest bet with the fans.
OR, they could play the next games with Gabe still being the star, and developing him as Dracula over the next few games, as a guy who heals drinking blood instead of using light magic and so on. It would feel sensibly different from the traditional Castlevania games, for sure, but I'm not sure it's a road unworthy of being explored.
I mean, I can totally imagine a game where you play as a Gabe on his path to becoming a vampire, where you can suck the blood of your enemies and briefly inherit their characteristics (drain a werewolf and become stronger and faster, or later on become capable of draining bloodless enemies and drain skeletons to grow a bone armor or medusa to fly around).
Heck, I'm sort of thinking of a CV game working more or less like the Assassin Creed games, with Dracula moving from Sofia to Paris to London and roamin the cities fighting other creatures of the night and feeding on the people. And doing all those sort of incredible things the "realistic" approach of most sandbox games don't let you do.
I can imagine Dracula sprinting over a rooftop before launching himself in a jump so high that he lands on one of Notre Dame's towers, smashing stones and letting debris falling on the ground. Or him fighting a summon demonic being in the middle of the London Bridge with terrified citizens running everywhere.
Yes yes I know, it's a wholly different game. It's somewhat of an heresy, but I'd be there day 1 anyways.
I think one potential advantage of still using Gabriel is that they can use a couple games to show him getting so cool and powerful and menacing and yes, even evil, that it builds up his character for the games where you're actually gonna try and bring him down as a Belmont. It worked wonders with Legacy of Kain. When you played as Kain, you knew you were gonna be the villain and when later you faced him, you could really think "he's the ruler of the Underworld and I really wouldn't want to fight him because I've seen what he's capable of".