Not the same. I said cloudesque as in similar, not exact alike. Learn to read.

At least cloud was kinda cool. Can't say that about that generic pathetic excuse of a hero jonafag is.
Also in sotn most of the weapons had something cool about them. A nice effect going off, an unique special attack and such.
Starting from aos all of the weapons started just being the same thing as previous weapon of the same class, only with a minor sprite difference and stat change.
Then dos added more of those and pork carbon copied most of dos's weapons and added few more. Their special moves are almost all generic and similar (character dashes forward while attacking), they have next to no cool effects on them etc.