To me, Castlevania is what defined my tastes in everything, or put in another way, it is the only thing that I found in my life that reunites everything I love. Haunting, gothic scenery, the best music in the world, based on classical, baroque, with touches of metal, jazz... great gameplay, be it with death pits or a gigantic castle with a lot of RPG elements (that's my favourite kind but I love both); and when it got perfect for me, it even added full anime look to the formula.
And I'm glad to read that so many people find the music to be the most or one of the most important parts.
For me, without the music it just isn't Castlevania, no matter how beautiful the stage and the characters are.
Music is the first thing I like, then there's the gothic, haunting, romantic horror look.
If I have those two elements I'm already happy and I love the game.
But as Judgment and CV:HD have proven, it's better to have the full package in the game, with gameplay and story.
I'd love to have death pits inside MetroidVania games, and I have no problem in the games being difficult, though I'm OK when they are easy too, that doesn't change how much I like a game.
And... what is a man? If he looks like Juste Belmont, it's something I want to take home when I return and display besides my bed lamp
