I didn't dislike PoR because of the art style. I don't care about such things, I was just appalled how boring and generic the levels were. But if you really thought PoR felt like a new and fresh entry in the series, good for you! I know I didn't.
And for the record, I actually liked DoS. But the formula was already beginning to feel stale. And PoR was merely a poor (or should I say PooR?) reproduction with worse level design and terrible fetch quests. Apart from that, it's a decent platformer but a below average Castlevania game. In my humble opinion.
In the end, it hasn't much to do with the actual quality of the games, but I can only buy the same game so many times, regardless of how great it once was.
I shall continue to bitch about these things, cause they matter to me. And all I initially wanted to say was that I don't believe OoE will turn out to be the BEST CASTLEVANIA EVAH. Which is what this topic is all about.