Eh, I found it to be more fun than DoS. Although to be fair, DoS and PoR are the only Castlevanias I've been able to play so far.
That said, I did prefer DoS's story, and Yoko>Charlotte. However, DoS also got VERY boring, VERY fast. PoR had more variety to offer, making it in my opinion more enjoyable. Hell, I loved Sisters mode, despite all the whining I hear about it.
EDIT: GameFAQs is designed for trolling. Dead serious.