Deservedly so. Many of the opinions on this forums are ridiculous (IMO). You've basically got a bunch of people who just flat out refuse to enjoy anything Cv unless is a carbon copy of every Cv that came before it. And when yet another carbon copy is delivered, those same people do little but bitch and complain about how nothing new is every done with the series.
The problem with Lords of Shadow is that it is very hard for many (not all) devotees to "enjoy" a game that is, to a sizable group of fans (including myself), tied to Castlevania primarily through names and locales, and little to naught else, bearing little semblance to Castlevania as much as to Insert-Hack-and-Slasher-Here.
Also, please don't speak for the whole. You're just making a sweeping generalization. Yes, those groups of fans do exist, but there are an equal amount that are open-minded about the series. You need to be mindful of your words and a lot more mindful of the people you're speaking to. This is a sensitive matter to many right now, especially with the lack of a 25th anniversary anything, and making inflammatory statements doesn't help it at all.
Dream all you want, MS is here to stay (at least for the next 2-3 years), and no amount of useless bitching is going to change that. You can either support your favorite series, or continue complain that it's not yet another carbon copy.
So running a survey and collecting statistics is now considered "useless bitching"? Last time I checked, it was called "peaceful protest." In this way, at least we are discussing ways to take some sort of incentive towards an opinion.
---------
Renonsgoods: You make some great points, and I can't argue much with you there. Although I dislike LoS, the Metroidvanias are becoming way too similar for their own good (although I still enjoy playing them), and so much potential for elaboration/depth/many other things was thrown out (see: PoR and the World War II setting seeming like a flimsy backdrop when it could've been so much more.)
----------
also:
It's a little hard not see LOS as the end of Castlevania when the fan base has been told to forget everything they know about Castlevania & been given the most unfaithful reboot conceivable (story wise atleast). I don't think there is any denying that turning Gabriel into Dracula is roughly the equivalent to giving Ganon a green hood & telling us that he is the new hero of time for a Zelda reboot.
I third this notion.