The utter entirety of Uzo's post.

Man, didn't D9 tell you not to go down this road?
I would like to vouch for my intial warning so that I don't get complaints against me down the road.
We're holding out on showing much of anything at this point because of the utter shock and awe that will be bestowed upon the fanbase when we hand out a true look at what they're going to get. It's not just because of totally new graphics music and story, but because it's a completely revamped game design and evolving it in the way it should have years ago. Taking the best of the series and pushing it all that much further.
You know he's going to gripe that you have "no proof," right? Not that that's going to faze you or anything, just giving a very probable heads-up.
Montoya, at this point, I'd just swallow your pride on this one, because it's like I told you; you won't beat Uzo in this area. Personal justifications have no substance here anymore, and Uzo's given irrefutable fact after fact and that alone makes his case outshine yours. Just let your personal vex with him go, and get back to discussing your game. There's no point in fighting on your feedback thread because you won't get anything of value, except maybe a headache. :/
EDIT: I hadn't caught this particular bit before, and I feel the need to address it.
Castlevania has a split fandom. There are those who want to see SOTN over and over again, and there are those of us who want, and welcome something new. Lords of Shadow is a godsend in my opinion, and of course the whole community backlashed at Mercury Steam because their game was different. I am trying to appeal to those who want something new in the 2D genre as well, and trust me, while they may not be the fans that nerd it up on these forums; they are out there and there are plenty of them.
So you really think that CV's fandom is THAT black-and-white?
[Insert "Bitch, please" meme here]
If that's what you think, I may have to seriously consider ceasing my involvement in your aspiring project. Not that you'd care. I'm sorry, but that kind of ignorant statement drives me just plain bonkers. YES, there are SotN-nerds who obsess over it and its similarities, and there are "old CV is too mainstream" people who wait for new-style games.
But there are those of us who are TRULY open minded enough to be both. And I consider my self just that. I love, love, LOVE SotN, and DoS, and PoRk, and OoE. But I like it when CV, or any series I like, takes a new twist and turn. Why? Because seeing a new game style that I hadn't even expected throws me off the linear path I have come to expect, and leaves me guessing for future installments in aforementioned series.
That being said, Lords of Shadow, as far as gameplay, and even parts of the plotline, were involved, it's hardly as "nothing-to-something" original as you say it is.
Lords of Shadow gameplay: Full-on explorer with heavy platforming and terrain maneuvering (see also; Devil May Cry, God of War, Dante's Inferno, etc., etc.)
Lords of Shadow plotline: Go on a bigass legendary epic quest, slaying legendary beast and demons galore, in search of personal purification and to be reunited with your loved one. Oh, and the final boss is Satan. (see also; Dante's Inferno)
That's not to say I hate LoS, I actually quite enjoyed it. It was refreshing to play a Castlevania-titled game and not say "oh, boy, giant bat boss, where's my axe/stopwatch," or "last stage, big staircase, Dracky in a chair, giant bat form, dead). And I don't hate those elements, either. But Lords was a nice blend, in my opinion, of Uncharted, Dante's Inferno, and God of War, but still managed to maintain that melancholy, dark Gothic feel that it uniquely Castlevania.
So your point kind of falls apart in my eyes. It's too black-and-white and makes no effort to acknowledge the grey area in the middle, and that really bothers me. Fandoms are unique, spontaneous, and eccentric as a whole, and are subject to any and all constant shifts based on the object of their fandom's growth, or lack thereof. Why on earth would you say that that's not the case? It's just baffling to me.