I never thought video games looked anything nearing realism, but I totally was wowed by graphics then whereas now my reaction is very much "meh." Part of that is due to me having been a kid at the time and being impressed by almost everything, but another reason is I just don't like how games have turned toward "realism" with grittier environments and a limited color palette. Games used to be fun to look at, where now a truly good-looking game is hard to come by.
I grew up in a different era and I don't like how things are now. Thankfully the Old still occasionally shines through. SUDA51 games are very much old-styled with spicings of the New. Handhelds still cling to cute mascots and colorful graphics and simpler gameplay. That's the kind of thing I like. It's not archaic, it's just a different way of doing things, and I wish it had a more prominent place in today's console world. When a game like Rayman Origins doesn't sell bazillions of copies, something's wrong.