At this point, i don't really care about the reputation HD has. Plus all the complaints about it are directed towards the graphics, but since when does graphics make the game??
That's like choosing a really crappy game with excellent graphics over a really good game that has crappy graphics.
It's more than just the graphics that people complained about. Subweapon grinding is
extremely tedious and a lot of rare item drops are much rarer than they really needed to be (both of which could've been done to artificially extend replay value), all characters are nerfed to some extent except for Soma, and the game just feels uninspired overall (especially when you compare it with games that share the same price tag, like Torchlight).
Graphics-wise, the only thing I didn't really like was how it was implied that this game was in HD, and that's kind of misleading.